← All Jobs
Feb 12, 2026

**Medicare Customer Service Senior Supervisor - Hybrid, AZ, PA, TX - arenaflex Healthcare**

Apply Now
**Join arenaflex Healthcare, a leading health insurance company, in shaping the future of customer service excellence. As a Medicare Customer Service Senior Supervisor, you will lead a team of licensed insurance agents in delivering exceptional customer experiences, driving retention results, and fostering a culture of growth and development.** **About arenaflex Healthcare** arenaflex Healthcare is a dynamic and innovative health insurance company dedicated to providing comprehensive coverage solutions to millions of Americans. With a strong commitment to customer-centricity, arenaflex Healthcare strives to make a positive impact on people's lives by delivering personalized care, support, and guidance. As a Medicare Customer Service Senior Supervisor, you will be part of a talented team that shares your passion for excellence and your drive to make a difference. **Key Responsibilities** As a Medicare Customer Service Senior Supervisor, you will be responsible for leading a team of licensed insurance agents in delivering exceptional customer experiences, driving retention results, and fostering a culture of growth and development. Your key responsibilities will include: * **Driving Customer Retention Results**: Lead the team in achieving customer retention goals, focusing on individual retention productivity, and ensuring activity standards are met. * **Leading, Coaching, and Developing the Conservation Team**: Concentrate on individual retention productivity, quality customer service, and customer loyalty, while ensuring that activity standards are met. * **Communicating Goals and Monitoring Results**: Communicate goals and monitor individual, team, and call center results to identify and act on both positive and negative trends, ensuring the attainment of financial and performance targets. * **Removing Barriers for Front-Line Staff**: Work to remove barriers for front-line staff to exceed customer expectations, ensuring that they have the necessary tools and support to deliver exceptional service. * **Hiring, Onboarding, and Training New Agents**: Hire, onboard, and train new agents to ensure they have the necessary skills and knowledge to deliver exceptional customer service. * **Managing Performance**: Manage performance through effective coaching and counseling, ensuring that agents are meeting their targets and providing exceptional service. * **Conducting Daily Call Monitoring**: Conduct daily call monitoring to identify coaching opportunities and reinforce learning through individual agent coaching and assessment of agent analytics. * **Resolving Escalated Customer Issues**: Resolve escalated customer issues, ensuring that customers receive timely and effective resolution. * **Leading the Team through Change**: Lead the team through change by developing a positive team relationship, fostering open communication, and promoting a culture of growth and development. * **Gathering Data and Evaluating Information**: Gather data, evaluate information, and present feedback to agents to enhance performance, overall productivity, and skill sets. **Requirements** To be successful in this role, you will need to possess the following qualifications and skills: * **High School Degree Required**: A high school degree is required, with a Bachelor's degree or equivalent work experience highly preferred. * **Excellent Interpersonal and Relationship Management Skills**: Excellent interpersonal and relationship management skills, with the ability to build strong relationships with agents, customers, and stakeholders. * **Excellent Oral, Written, and Presentation Skills**: Excellent oral, written, and presentation skills, with the ability to communicate effectively with agents, customers, and stakeholders. * **3 or More Years of Successful Call Center Experience**: 3 or more years of successful call center experience, with a proven track record of decreasing operating costs in a phone-based environment. * **Health Insurance License Required**: A health insurance license is required, with a strong understanding of Medicare and other supplemental health products. * **Ability to Multi-Task and Drive Results**: The ability to multi-task, drive results, think strategically, and implement a new business growth strategy. * **2 or More Years of People Management Experience**: 2 or more years of people management experience, with a proven track record of leading high-performing teams. * **Extensive Background in Medicare and Other Supplemental Health Products**: An extensive background in Medicare and other supplemental health products, with experience in upselling customers to another product. * **Working Proficiency with Metrics, Measurements, Reports, and Operations**: Working proficiency with metrics, measurements, reports, and operations, with the ability to analyze data and make informed decisions. * **Strong Organizational and Analytical Skills**: Strong organizational and analytical skills, with the ability to result in conclusive recommendations. * **Expert Knowledge of Salesforce, Excel, PowerPoint, and Office Products**: Expert knowledge of Salesforce, Excel, PowerPoint, and Office products, with the ability to use these tools to drive results and improve performance. **Nice-to-Haves** * **Experience with Upselling Customers to Another Product**: Experience with upselling customers to another product, with a proven track record of increasing sales and revenue. * **Working Proficiency with CRM Systems**: Working proficiency with CRM systems, with the ability to use these tools to drive results and improve performance. **Benefits** As a Medicare Customer Service Senior Supervisor at arenaflex Healthcare, you will enjoy a range of benefits, including: * **Competitive Salary and Bonus Structure**: A competitive salary and bonus structure, with opportunities for growth and advancement. * **Comprehensive Health Insurance**: Comprehensive health insurance, including medical, dental, and vision coverage. * **Retirement Plan**: A retirement plan, with a company match to help you save for your future. * **Paid Time Off**: Paid time off, including vacation, sick leave, and holidays. * **Professional Development Opportunities**: Professional development opportunities, including training, coaching, and mentorship. * **Flexible Work Arrangements**: Flexible work arrangements, including remote work options and flexible hours. **How to Apply** If you are a motivated and results-driven leader with a passion for customer service excellence, we encourage you to apply for this exciting opportunity. Please submit your resume and a cover letter outlining your qualifications and experience. We look forward to hearing from you! Apply Now